Historic Buildings The Samuel Lawrence House, built 1825, remodeled 1866. Greek revival Penn Yan United Methodist Church Edson Potter House, built about 1888, is at 160 Main Street. Elaborate details make this a fascinating structure. Cobblestone Springs, south of Himrod. October 2017. The Fox Inn at 158 Main Street in Penn Yan, was built in about 1824 by William Oliver. Bed-and-breakfast for sale in 2018. Carefully restored and meticulously painted, the Theodore Wheeler House at 301 Main St, Penn Yan, Summer 2016. Cobblestone Springs, south elevation. The Post House, at 215 Main Street. A side view of the Post House Beautiful interior stain glass windows, inside The First Methodist Church. Beautiful interior stain glass windows, inside The First Methodist Church. Share this: Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook Like Loading...